- Cheapest guaranteed featured unit: Wuthering Waves at 160 pulls worst case (80 hard pity + 50/50)
- HSR, Genshin and ZZZ tie at 180 pulls worst case with near-identical 0.6% / 90-pull systems
- Outlanders guarantees featured within 120 pulls once per banner* — best on paper, newest rules, biggest asterisk
- NIKKE is the outlier: no rising odds, but a deterministic 200-ticket spark that carries over
- Rankings use worst-case pulls; your expected cost is much lower — run your own pity through the calculator
“Best pity” arguments usually compare vibes. This one compares the only number that can’t argue back: the worst-case pull count to a guaranteed featured unit, plus the base rate, the 50/50 rules, and whether your progress carries over. Rules below are the late-2026 published banner structures, linked per game.
Quick Answer: The Ranking
| Game | Worst case (featured) | Base 5★ rate | 50/50? | Carry-over |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Monster Hunter Outlanders* | 120 pulls (once per banner) | 0.6% SSR | Yes | Not documented — assume no |
| Wuthering Waves | 160 pulls | 0.8% | Yes | Yes, across event banners |
| Honkai: Star Rail | 180 pulls | 0.6% | Yes | Yes, same banner type |
| Genshin Impact | 180 pulls | 0.6% | Yes | Yes, same banner type |
| Zenless Zone Zero | 180 pulls | 0.6% | Yes | Yes, same banner type |
| NIKKE | 200 pulls (ticket spark) | 4% SSR / 2% feat. | No 50/50 | Tickets carry over |
*Outlanders’ 120-pull featured guarantee applies once per banner under launch-era rules (GameWith, Nov 2026). Everything else here has years of stable rules; Outlanders has weeks. Weight that accordingly — and check the in-game odds before every banner.
If you only remember one line: WuWa has the cheapest proven guarantee, the HoYoverse trio ties for second, NIKKE trades the highest pull count for full determinism.
Honkai: Star Rail — The Reference Design
Character Event Warp: 0.6% base 5-star rate, soft pity from around pull 74 (community-estimated), hard pity at 90. Each 5-star is a 50/50 between featured and standard; lose it and the next 5-star is guaranteed featured, so the featured character lands within 180 pulls worst case. Pity and guarantees carry across banners of the same type. (Light Cone banners run a tighter 80-pull pity.) Sources: community wiki summary, Oct 30 2026, banner rules roundup, Oct 20 2026.
Genshin Impact and Zenless Zone Zero — Same Skeleton
Both mirror HSR’s structure: 0.6% base rate, 90-pull hard pity, 50/50 with same-type carry-over, 180-pull worst case (multi-game rate table, late 2026). ZZZ’s soft pity sits a pull or two earlier (~73 vs ~74), which changes expected cost by almost nothing. For budgeting purposes these three are one system: plan any limited character as a 180-pull worst case and be pleasantly surprised most of the time.
Wuthering Waves — The Generous One
WuWa undercuts the trio on every axis: 0.8% base rate, soft pity around pull 66, hard pity at 80, and the same 50/50-then-guaranteed structure with carry-over across event banners (pity comparison, rate tables). Worst case: 160 pulls. Its weapon banner skips the coin flip entirely — the featured 5-star weapon is guaranteed at pity. This is the game your pity dollar stretches furthest in.
NIKKE — Expensive but Honest
NIKKE refuses the whole rising-odds model: flat 4% SSR, 2% featured (1% on Pilgrim/Over-Spec), no soft pity, no 50/50. The guarantee is Gold Mileage: one ticket per pull, 200 buys the featured unit outright, and tickets carry over. Worst case is the highest count here — and the only one with zero luck involved after the spark. High spenders who hate variance genuinely prefer it; everyone else should note the $774.90 repeat-price spark cost before committing to a banner.
Monster Hunter Outlanders — Best Asterisk
0.6% SSR, SSR guaranteed by pull 90, and the featured Adventurer guaranteed within 120 pulls once per banner, with a 50/50 split (GameWith gacha hub, Nov 2026, banner guide, Nov 9 2026). On paper that 120 beats WuWa’s 160. In practice: “once per banner” caps the generosity, carry-over is undocumented, and launch-month rules in live games get tuned. Rank it first with a pencil, not a pen — and read our Outlanders gacha cost guide before budgeting a banner.
Weapon Pity Is a Different Game
Everything above covers characters. Weapons run side systems with their own counters — and their own traps:
HSR Light Cones pity at 80 pulls with a 75/25 featured split, tighter than the character 90. Genshin’s Epitomized Path adds fate points toward a chosen weapon, but those points reset with each weapon banner (Genshin pity explainer, Oct 30 2026) — never start an Epitomized path you can’t finish. ZZZ’s W-Engine channel is likewise separate from agent pity. WuWa simply guarantees the featured 5-star weapon at pity with no coin flip, the most forgiving weapon system here. NIKKE and Outlanders have no weapon gacha to budget.
The practical rule: price weapons as a second banner, not a side quest. A “complete” character (unit plus signature weapon) can cost double the headline worst case in every HoYoverse game.
Which System Punishes Skipping Least
Skipping a banner you don’t want is free in every game with carry-over — your pulls and guarantees wait for the next one. Ranked by skip-friendliness: WuWa first (cross-event carry, cheapest ceiling), the HoYoverse trio tied second (same-type carry), NIKKE third (tickets persist, but each skip just banks toward the same 200), Outlanders last (assume every banner starts from zero). Full rules per game live in our pity carry-over guide.
Which Pity Is Best for You
Free-to-play: WuWa — lowest worst case plus the highest base rate means free pulls convert best. NIKKE’s flat rates with no pity ramp punish low pull counts most.
Monthly pass / light spender: the HoYoverse trio. Predictable 180-pull math, deep free-currency income, and years of stable rules. Run your saved pity through the gacha pity calculator before each banner — most limited characters cost far less than worst case.
Guarantee-chasers: NIKKE. Nothing else lets you buy certainty at a fixed ticket price with full carry-over. Just know the price tag first: the 200-pull spark math is essential reading.
Planning to the ceiling keeps one unlucky banner from wrecking your month. In a 90-pull system most 5-stars land between pulls 74 and 90 — but “most” is cold comfort when you’re the outlier. Our guide to stop overspending on gacha games builds the full ceiling-first routine.
What the Worst Cases Cost in Cash
Pull counts convert to money through each game’s top-up packs. Our calculator’s US pack math (repeat prices, before free currency): 180-pull worst case ≈ $360.89, WuWa’s 160-pull worst case ≈ $319.91, a single 90-pull pity ≈ $183.93 (gacha pity calculator). NIKKE’s spark: ≈$774.90. Outlanders dollar costs depend on your store’s Rutacoin packs — price them with the banner pity math before pulling.
Where Hunter Vault fits: it’s our own app, so read this as a recommendation from the people who build it. Pity math tells you what a banner could cost; a budget decides what it will cost. Log each game’s banner spending in real money — the microtransaction tracker guide shows the one-place setup — and pity stops being a surprise.
Final Takeaway
WuWa wins on generosity, the HoYoverse trio wins on predictability, NIKKE wins on determinism, and Outlanders wins on paper with an asterisk. Pick the system that matches how you spend — then budget the worst case and enjoy beating it. And whichever game takes most of your money deserves a monthly number of its own, not just vibes. Revisit this ranking yearly: pity rules hold for years, then one generous update reorders the table overnight. Until then, your pity strategy is simple — know your worst case, save for one banner at a time, and let the guarantees do the worrying for you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which gacha game has the best pity system?
By worst-case pulls, Wuthering Waves: a featured 5-star is guaranteed within 160 pulls (80-pull hard pity plus a 50/50 guarantee), against 180 in Honkai: Star Rail, Genshin Impact and Zenless Zone Zero. Monster Hunter Outlanders guarantees its featured unit within 120 pulls once per banner, which beats everything on paper — but it is a new system with launch-era rules, so treat that asterisk seriously.
What is the difference between soft pity and hard pity?
Hard pity is the published ceiling: a 5-star is guaranteed by that pull. Soft pity is the community-observed ramp before it, where odds quietly rise — around pull 74 in the HoYoverse games, around pull 66 in Wuthering Waves. Soft pity is estimated from player data, not published by the developers.
Is NIKKE pity good or bad?
Different, not worse. NIKKE has no rising odds and no 50/50: every pull is a flat 4% SSR chance. The guarantee is Gold Mileage — 200 tickets buy the featured Nikke outright, and tickets carry over. The spark costs more pulls than anyone else, but it is fully deterministic.
How much does a guaranteed limited character cost?
At US repeat prices: about $360.89 for a 180-pull worst case in the HoYoverse games, $319.91 for Wuthering Waves' 160-pull worst case (both per our pity calculator's pack math). NIKKE's 200-pull spark runs about $774.90 at repeat prices. Free currency and saved pity cut all of these a long way down.
Should I pull on the standard banner?
Only with free standard currency, never with premium pulls you could spend on limited banners. Standard pools never contain the featured unit, standard pity never transfers to limited banners, and limited pity is where guarantees — and your budget — actually live.